Calm turquoise canal beside a vintage ivory waterfront condo and a newer glass-balcony building in Bay Harbor Islands.

How Bay Harbor Islands Condos Are Priced Right Now

In 1953 a two-story condominium building went up on about a third of an acre at 9110 West Bay Harbor Drive. It looked across the water to the golf course in Indian Creek Village. In 2022 an affiliate of Menachem Kranz bought all ten units for $6.5 million, which The Real Deal worked out to $650,000 per unit. The plan was to replace the building with a boutique condo. Landau Properties later bought the site from Kranz for $8.5 million, according to The Real Deal. The project planned for the site is Indian Creek Residences & Yacht Club. All nine of its residences had sold by November 21, 2025, at average pricing of about $1,900 per square foot, as Traded reported.

That one parcel holds the whole pricing story of this town. A Bay Harbor Islands condo trades in one of two markets. One is a resale market where buyers have time and leverage. The other is a land market where developers compete for the ground under older buildings and then presell new homes at prices the resale side never reaches. If you are comparing buildings here, the useful question is which of the two markets a unit really belongs to.

The Town's Quarterly Numbers Blend Both Markets

Florida REALTORS released its third-quarter 2026 local figures on October 16. For July through September 2026, Bay Harbor Islands recorded 36 townhouse and condo closings. That was 44% more than in the same quarter of 2025. The median sale price was $670,000, up 31.4% year over year, and the average was $1,014,639, up 40%. Dollar volume for the quarter came to $36.5 million, up 101.7%.

The average sits about 50% above the median. In a town this small, a gap that wide means a cluster of modestly priced sales is sharing a spreadsheet with a smaller number of far more expensive ones. The median tells you about the typical vintage unit. The average is being pulled upward by the closings in new boutique buildings. Read on its own, the headline growth figure says little about either market.

The Resale Market Moves Slowly

The same third-quarter 2026 report counted 156 active townhouse and condo listings in Bay Harbor Islands. That works out to 15.6 months of supply. Median time to contract was 126 days, and sellers received 90.2% of original list price.

The neighbors give those numbers context. Next door in Bal Harbour, the third quarter of 2026 showed 12.5 months of supply and a 46-day median to contract. Miami-Dade County as a whole had 12.3 months of supply and a 76-day median. So a resale listing in Bay Harbor Islands usually waits longer for a contract than one across the bridge, and the seller usually gives up close to a tenth of the original asking price. For a buyer looking at an existing unit, that is room to negotiate, and the town's own data supports it.

New Construction Sells Before It Is Finished

New construction runs on a very different clock. PPG Development and L3C Capital Partners topped off Bay Harbor Towers at 10141 East Bay Harbor Drive in November 2025. The building has eight stories and 44 residences of 1,857 to 4,902 square feet. According to Florida YIMBY, it was 75% sold at topping off, with the remaining residences starting at $2.6 million, and penthouses from $10 million. At the time of that December 2025 report, the developer was targeting completion in the third quarter of 2026.

Origin Bay Harbor, VDA's 27-unit project at 9760 West Bay Harbor Drive, had 20 units presold at $3.8 million to $4.5 million when the developer secured a $30.5 million construction loan. The Real Deal reported in July 2025 that construction had begun that April and that completion was expected in 2026. Continuum's La Baia North, 57 residences at 9481 East Bay Harbor Drive, topped off on April 25, 2026, with completion anticipated in 2027, per Florida YIMBY. Regency Development's La Maré Regency Collection, 33 residences at 9927 East Bay Harbor Drive, closed a $55.7 million construction loan arranged by JLL, and the January 2025 announcement put completion in the second quarter of 2026. Onda Residences at 1135 103rd Street finished construction and received its temporary certificate of occupancy in the summer of 2024.

Across the two markets, the arithmetic is lopsided. In the third quarter of 2026, the median sale price was $670,000, and the median listing took 126 days to reach a contract. Over the same stretch, new residences in the same town were contracted at several times that price, often years before anyone could move in. Traded reported that Bay Harbor Islands price per square foot rose about 93% over the two years before its November 2025 article. Most of that gain was captured by brand-new product.

The Lot Connects the Two Markets

New buildings need sites, and on a small island town with fixed shorelines, many of those sites already hold mid-century condos. The 9110 West Bay Harbor Drive deal shows the mechanics. Ten owners of a 1953 building sold together at $650,000 a unit. The nine residences planned for the same ground then sold out at an average of about $1,900 a foot. The same year, Bay Harbor Towers' earlier building sold as a whole to a buyer led by PPG's Ari Pearl, at about $1.07 million per unit according to the South Florida Business Journal. That site is now the 44-residence tower described above. Some development land trades without an occupied building on it. In February 2024, ABH Developer Group paid $7.5 million for the permitted Aire Residences site at 9700 West Bay Harbor Drive, planned as a seven-story, eight-unit building, as The Real Deal reported.

The wider forces behind deals like these are regional. In October 2024 the Miami Herald reported that condo assessment fees had risen nearly 60% in Miami-Dade and Broward. The paper also reported that developers favor bayfront and beachfront land, with developer Ian Bruce Eichner calling such sites "inherently invaluable pieces of land." Bisnow reported in October 2025 that associations in aging South Florida buildings, facing repair costs, higher fees and insurance premiums, were approaching developers about buyouts.

So a vintage unit in Bay Harbor Islands has two possible buyers. One is a resident, who compares it with 155 other listings and expects to pay about 90% of the original asking price. The other is a developer, who compares the whole building with the cost of a new site. Both 2022 deals came from small waterfront buildings with a handful of owners, and their per-unit prices were roughly in line with or above today's $670,000 resale median.

Reading a Specific Building Through That Lens

This changes how two similar listings should be compared. Picture two units with the same layout and the same asking price. One sits in a ten-unit building on the water along West Bay Harbor Drive, and the other is in a larger building on an interior lot. They are priced by different buyers. The first has a second potential buyer in the background, because its site resembles the ones that have already traded to developers. The second is priced almost entirely against 15.6 months of competing supply. The second listing may be the better home for you. But the first carries value that a price-per-square-foot comparison will not show, and its owners may be slower to cut their price because of it.

A new-construction contract needs a different kind of reading. The prices at Bay Harbor Towers and Origin reflect delivery, finishes and the absence of decades-old building systems, and buyers there commit before completion. When you weigh one of those contracts against a resale, compare the delivery target and the deposit schedule with the discount the resale market is giving right now. That discount is real in the third-quarter 2026 data, and it shows up most in the buildings no developer is likely to want.

The town page for Bal Harbour, Bay Harbor Islands and Surfside has more on the surrounding streets. For the retail anchor a few minutes south, our recent piece on Bal Harbour Shops covers what has opened there.

If you are weighing a vintage unit against a pre-construction contract in Bay Harbor Islands, Shayna Davidov Hanson represents buyers in exactly that comparison and can look at recent sales and site characteristics with you, building by building. Request a Private Consultation.

Work With Shayna

Working for Fortune 100, 200 and 500 clientele in Business Development and Public Relations in both the United States and Latin America has given Ms. Davidov Hanson an acute sense of business savvy, negotiation skills and the ability to relate and work with an array of personalities, cultures and levels of sophistication.

Follow Me on Instagram